Behind the Façades in France: What expats and the mainstream media (French and American alike) fail to notice (or fail to tell you) about French attitudes, principles, values, and official positions…
Jim Grimsley penned an editorial last week in the Los Angeles Times that accused white people—all white people—of being racist.
Unfortunately for the gay columnist and playwright, one Benny Huang plans to examine the issue of racism in a dispassionate manner and, indeed, to take the argument to its logical conclusions.
Grimsley, who is white and grew up in Georgia at the tail-end of the
Jim Crow era, railed against the cluelessness of white America on the
issue of race. Even white people who consider themselves enlightened on
racial issues, he argues, are often unaware of the racism that lurks
within their own hearts. “…I have found that black people are all too
aware that progress on racial issues has hardly moved forward at all,
while white people are nearly as blind to their racism as ever,” he
wrote.
I wish Grimsley had been clearer on one point—that is, whether white
racism is cultural or genetic. Within the space of the same sentence he
seems to blame both nature and nurture for white racism. Grimsely
writes: “…[T]hese are symptoms of the insanity of white culture and our
refusal to understand that racism is part of our makeup — each and every
one of us, north, south, east and west — from cradle to grave.”
… The idea that white people are irredeemably racist is central to the
social justice movement. All white people are racist, even good white
liberals.
… Enter Tim Wise, another white southerner. He may be America’s best
known “anti-racist activist” and he’s pretty extreme in his beliefs.
Wise has made a career out of countering anti-black racism, most of
which is entirely fictional, with anti-white racism. Even Wise admits to
harboring certain racist tendencies though he blames it on growing up
in a “white supremacist” culture. He nonetheless believes, despite his
efforts to be the best friend black people have ever had, that he has
internalized certain racist attitudes. And no, he isn’t talking about
racist attitudes towards whites though that would at least be true.
According to Tim Wise, icon of “anti-racism,” even Tim Wise can’t claim to have washed away the stain of racism. Without exception, all white people must be racist.
… It should be noted here that this attitude [Tribalism] has existed in all time
and in all places. The only societies in history that have even tried to
resist the tribalist urge are modern Western societies—this is, white
societies of the post-World War II era. If you regard tribalism as
negative–and in most cases I do—then Europe and North America are
actually paragons of virtue. Colorblindness is an idea that modern
Westerners have strived for even if they have not perfectly achieved it.
Within those societies, it’s the white majority that has been the most
willing to suppress their instincts. Other races seem less enthused
about colorblindness. They have demanded and received preference which they will cling to from now until eternity.
… The idea that we’re born racist, something I think at least some
social justice warriors would agree with as long as we’re discussing
only white people, has certain ramifications. If we accept it (and I
do), we must accept that racism will always exist. The war against
racism can never be won but we can lose our freedom fighting it.
I’ve noticed that liberals often use human nature as an excuse for
behaviors that would otherwise be rejected. If we have an urge, what’s
the use of trying to suppress it? Consider homosexuality, for example, a
behavior regarded as aberrant by nearly every society prior to the late
Twentieth Century. Putting aside moral and religious arguments for a
moment, homosexuality comes with certain health risks, particularly the
male variety—rectal cancer, AIDS, gonorrhea, etc.
(In a previous column, Benny Huang talked of
doctors who, while gallantly joining in the battles on smoking and fast food, live in fear that their careers will be summarily
ended if they advise against anal sodomy—which turns out to be far from bad medical
advice, no matter how you slice it.)
But don’t tell that to liberals. “Gays” are just “born that way” they
argue with very little evidence. No “gay” gene has ever been found and
studies indicate that children exposed to sexual abuse tend to become
homosexuals. Liberals reject this notion because they believe that
homosexuality is not a choice. Homosexuals therefore have no obligation
to suppress their urges. Be your true to yourself, they say. Telling
anyone that homosexuality is shameful is a form of abuse because it
forces that person into the proverbial closet.
It’s a mystery to me how homosexuality differs from racism if they are
both inborn traits. According to dogma, “gays” couldn’t stop being “gay”
any more than a leopard could change his spots. But isn’t the same true
of racists? If racists are born, not made, then even heavy guilt
tactics won’t cure them. What’s the point of trying to make racists
change? All of this “racist shaming” seems both pointless and
destructive to its subjects.
As a certified “homophobe” I am often asked if “gays” choose to be
“gay.” I always answer the same: yes, because people choose who they
sleep with. That doesn’t satisfy the homofascists who always respond,
“If being gay were a choice, who would choose it?”
… The social penalty for homosexuality is non-existent. The same cannot
be said about the social penalty for racism. You can lose your job for
the slightest episode of racism, real or perceived, which is really
hypocritical in that everyone is at least a little racist.
A simple question demands to be answered: do people choose to be
racist? If say you say no, then what’s the point of shaming them?
They’re beyond reformation. If you say yes, that necessitates a
follow-up question—if racism is a choice, who would choose it knowing
that it would mean living life as a pariah? Certainly no one I know
would knowingly accept the social penalty that comes with harboring
forbidden thoughts. It must therefore be an inborn characteristic.
As protesters across America keep marching and rioting (to the delight of the founder of the 1619 Project) to protest
police brutality against George Floyd and other blacks —
something described as a result of systemic racism or institutional
racism — Bob Woodson has been keeping busy this summer, appearing on Tucker CarlsonTonight, on Lou DobbsTonight, on the Mark Levin show, on radio, and with an op-ed in The Wall Street Journal, in which he wrote that Riots Invite Crime, Not Justice (Blacks end up suffering more when hostility to police makes it impossible to maintain urban order):
If racial profiling is wrong, it is equally wrong to stereotype all
police based on the actions of a few. The killing of George Floyd was
heinous, and justice must be served. But violent protests against police
are not the answer.
Elsewhere, the founder of the Woodson Center and the 1776 Unites initiative added that if the protestors want a police-free environment, they should move to Mexico, where there is no 911 number to call and where militia-type groups must be formed for self-protection.
Former civil rights activist Bob Woodson issued a sweeping indictment … of both the Black Lives Matter movement and the idea that "systemic racism" is the cause of African-American hardship in the U.S.
"I don't know what systemic racism is. Maybe someone can explain what that means," he told "Tucker Carlson Tonight."
Carlson responded by asserting that it was "a way to make people be
quiet and stop asking questions about economics, as far as I can tell."
… Woodson told Carlson that he left the movement because he "realized
that many of the people who suffered most -- poor blacks -- do not
benefit from the change -- that they're demographics were used by some
of those leaders."
"It's more class than it is race ... and now
race is being used to deflect attention away from the failures of people
running those institutions," he added. "The question is why
are black kids failing in school systems run by their own people?"
"When
Eric Holder was a U.S. Attorney in Washington, D.C., a lot of young
people were shot by the police, but they were black police shooting
black kids and not one was prosecuted. But there was no public
outcry because as long as illegality or evil wears a black face, then
it escapes detection and that's what's wrong with looking life through
the prism of race."
Woodson also suggested that much of black suffering was the result of Democratic leadership.
"In
the past 50 years, $22 trillion has been spent on poverty programs. Seventy percent goes not to the poor but those who serve poor people," he said.
"So many of those people taking office use this money to create a
class of people who are running these cities, and now after 50 years of
liberal Democrats running the inner cities, where we have all of these
inequities that we have, race is being used as a ruse, as a means
of deflecting attention away from critical questions such as why are
poor blacks failing in systems run by their own people?"
To answer Bob Woodson's initial question, "systemic racism" means, according to Glenn Reynolds, that
THERE AREN’T ENOUGH SPECIFIC EXAMPLES OF RACISM TO POINT TO, SO THEY HAVE TO CHANGE THE TERMS OF THE ARGUMENT
Similar with the racism hoaxes (not to be disconnected from the ubiquitous rape hoaxes). Ed Driscoll, who links to a list of 67 Hate Crime Hoaxes, makes the following conclusion:
In Mugged (Racial Demagoguery from the Seventies to Obama), Ann Coulter writes as follows:
Liberals claim Republicans speak in racist code words for the simple reason that Republicans aren't saying anything that's objectively racist. The idea of looking past people's words and actions to discover some secret motive comes straight from the communist playbook
… Like Captain Ahab searching for the great white whale, journalists are constantly on the hunt for proof that America was a white-supremacist wonderland
… Liberals are incapable of formulating an argument without accusing someone of racism. We don't like this, so who's the racist?
… standard Republican positions on small government, low taxes and tough-on-crime policies are supposed to be proof of racism. That's convenient. Since there is nothing objectively racist about these policy stances, liberals explain that they are "dog whistles" "slick racism," "subtle racism" or "code words" that secretly convey: "I hate black people."
… Republican positions are not code words for racism. Rather, liberals use "racism" as a code word for Republican positions.
Back to Bob Woodson — On Lou Dobbs, the founder of 1776 Unites makes the following comments:
This is a fight against … the credentials of this country … slavery was a stain [beyond] which we moved … This is really a struggle for the soul of this nation. Lincoln [and the Emancipation Memorial] are a symbol of redemption, and the Left does not believe in redemption. … One of the steps of defeating truth is to destroy evidence of the truth. Because these statues, like the Emancipation Memorial, are evidence of America's redemption from slavery, it's important for [the Left] to remove evidence of the truth.
On another Dobbs segment, writes Charles Creitz, the founder of 1776 Unites makes the following comments:
…This isn’t about social justice. Low-income black America is being used to promote insurrection in the country, and anarchy.
… This is not about social justice … And,
again, low-income black America are being used by the group to
promote insurrection in the country, and anarchy.
… My message to guilty white people [is] stop helping us! Just stop helping us!
• The Departure of Bari Weiss: "Propagandists", Ethical Collapse, and the "New McCarthyism" — "The radical left are running" the New York Times, "and no dissent is tolerated"
• 1619: It takes an absurdly blind fanaticism to insist that today’s free and prosperous America is rotten and institutionally oppressive
• The MSM newsrooms and their public shaming terror campaigns — the "bullying campus Marxism" is closer to cult religion than politics: Unceasingly searching out thoughtcrime, the American left has lost its mind
• Inciting Hate Already in Kindergarten:
1619 "Education" Is Part of Far-Left Indoctrination by People Who Hate
America to Kids in College, in School, and Even in Elementary Classes
As we predicted weeks before the 2008 vote, the (then-hypothetical) election of Barack Obama would in no way bring an end, not to American racism, but to accusations of American racism.
In its issue immediately prior to the 2016 elections, Charlie Hebdo was back to its tired old prejudices and its tired old tricks, saying Obama [Would] Again Be a [U.S.] Citizen Like All the Others, while the poor black man (victim) is forced to flee under a hail of bullets fired by white police officers. In the meantime, Jean-Yves Camus reports on the alt-right (Ku Klux Klan Without the Hoods) while a "Jacob Hamburger" compares The Donald to (sigh) a cowboy and a gangster.
A couple of weeks prior to the 2008 election, I wrote a post asking a series of questions…
(By how many percentage points must Barack Obama win for "America" to
"prove" (to itself as well as to others) that it is no longer racist? … What if the Illinois senator wins by, say, 60%? That's a pretty
impressive victory by any standard. But does that mean that the other
40% must necessarily be racists? Must race be the only, or the main,
reason for their voting against Obama? … And how about the future? Given that one in seven Americans is black
(it's actually about 12.85% or closer to one in eight, but since we are
talking about presidential terms, seven is an easier figure to handle),
must Americans from now on elect an African-American every seven
election cycles to prove they aren't racist? … Or must Americans make up for the 220 years without an African-American at
the helm, meaning that the next six presidents (the total number of
white males in the White House, 43, divided by 7) must be black.)
Here was/is the point of the questions
What is the point about these questions? The point is as follows:
Make no mistake about it. Should Obama win the election, the
hand-wringing and wild charges about American racism — both at home and
abroad — will at best cease temporarily. Any opposition to President
Obama's policies will be construed as racism "rearing its ugly head"
again.
And at best (at best, according to the — non-thinking —
bean-counters, that is), in the faraway future, we will be told by the
snickerers and the snorters: "Well yeah, a black American was elected
in 2008 (even reelected in 2012), but that was a one-time travesty!"
Or
they will say that oh, sure there is an African-Americans (there are
African-Americans) whom Americans have elected president, but… his (but their) skin color wasn't dark enough. "Would they ever" — insert knowing ironic smile here — "elect a really dark Negro?"
… Why does this come up? Because Americans — or certainly, conservative Americans from small town America — must be accused of something sinister. If it isn't racism, it's fascism. If it isn't fascism, it's something else. Americans must be treacherous, they must be greedy, they must be warmongers, they must be reactionary, they must be clueless. And…
they must be racist.
… the basic truth about racism is as follows:
racism is far less an accurate description of an attitude prevalent in a
given society, in a given individual, than it is a weapon that is
wielded to demonize one's opponents while making oneself appear heroic
by parroting (and by doing nothing else than parroting) politically
correct platitudes. More often than not, in other words, the fight
against alleged pockets of racism is nothing more noble than a
self-serving act of self-praise.
As I wrote in the subtitle, Every Crisis Is a Triumph, and examples of this were mentioned briefly:
The numerous pitfalls of Obamacare? The Iranian deal leading to a
greater chance of terrorism and war? The drama queens are fine with
that, they don't even mind being blamed for having made "mistakes," it
all leads to more crises down the road and a greater need for
intervention, ever more intervention from politicians and bureaucrats
and members of the Intervention Party the Democrat Party, aka knights in shining armor.
Gang shootings occur almost exclusively in minority areas. Police use
of force is most likely in confrontations with violent and resisting
criminals, and those confrontations happen disproportionately in
minority communities.
… Officers are routinely surrounded by hostile, jeering crowds when
they try to conduct a street investigation or make an arrest. Resistance
to arrest is up, officers report. Cops have been repeatedly told by
President Obama and the media that pedestrian stops and public order
enforcement are racist. In consequence, they are doing less of those
discretionary activities in high-crime minority communities.
The result? Violent crime is rising in cities with large black
populations.
• Barack Obama and his kindred spirits (white or black) in organizations such as the Black Lives Matter movement (a phoenix-like resurrection of Obama's ACORN, according to some) decry racism (real or exaggerated) in American society. (Check Powerline's Paul Mirengoff for an example of bogus allegations of racism.)
• Protests against racism and racists mount throughout the media and throughout society, particularly after violent encounters between members of opposing races (no matter what the context may have been).
• Hostility against police leads to officers becoming either the targets of "understandable" retaliation and revenge (including shootings and killings) by the alleged "victims" of racism or becoming the targets of the valiant anti-racism crusaders at the helm of society (demonization by intrepid members of the MSM and/or lawsuits by gallant attorneys general, etc…)
• Police officers, as concerned (if not more) at being labeled (and pursued as) bigots and racists as being shot at by members of minorities, consequently develop a far-from-unwell-founded timidity about engaging and patrolling minority communities — where most blacks are killed (in black-on-black crimes, by the way).
• With police absent (or less prominent) in inner-city neighborhoods, criminals feel more secure and violence explodes.
• Guess where more violence in inner-city neighborhoods (and its corollary, more black deaths) take us? That's right — we are back to step 1! You remember: that step where Obama and his kindred spirits decry racism and violence in American society; they now have even more nightmarish statistics that they can use to decry even more racism and violence in American society.
By the way, Heather Mac Donald's New York Post story on The Lies Told by the Black Lives Matter Movement ends with this paragraph:
For the past two decades, the country has been talking about phantom
police racism in order to avoid talking about a more uncomfortable
truth: black crime. But in the era of data-driven law enforcement,
policing is simply a function of crime. The best way to lower
police-civilian contacts in inner-city neighborhoods would be for
children to be raised by their mother and their father in order to
radically lower the crime rate there.
Americans are being told, by their fellow citizens as well as by foreigners, that in order to prove that they no longer are racist, they must elect a black man to the White House.
That is good to know.
But one question arises. By how many percentage points must Barack Obama win for "America" to "prove" (to itself as well as to others) that it is no longer racist? It would seem that only something in the neighborhood of a 99% victory could effectively determine that. But that is the kind of "victory" only seen in dictatorships, so hopefully a victory in that kind of numbers won't be required.
What if the Illinois senator wins by, say, 60%? That's a pretty impressive victory by any standard. But does that mean that the other 40% must necessarily be racists? Must race be the only, or the main, reason for their voting against Obama?
What if it's a razor-thin victory? Should the former community organizer win by only, say, 50.02%, will that mean that Americans aren't that ready to give up the racism that has (allegedly) characterized them for so long?
And how about four years from now? Must Americans again prove that they are not (or that they are no longer) racist? Come the 2012 election, must Americans reelect President Obama to the White House to prove they are not fettered by racism? Again, by how many percentage points? And what if a hypothetically impressive 2008 victory turns into a hypothetically lackluster 2012 showing? Will we then be told, ominously, that that proves that racism "rears its ugly head" again?
And what if the results of the election aren't that straightforward? Remember 2000? What if Obama comes out ahead (barely), only to have John McCain — for valid reasons or otherwise — mount a campaign to recount the votes in some state(s) or parts thereof? What if Obama's victory is not ascertained until several weeks after November 4? Can you imagine the outcry that will cause? (Let's not even imagine the hollering, the wailing, and the gnashing of teeth among American leftists as well as foreign ones, should Obama be the candidate who loses after a year-2000-election scenario!)
And how about the future? Given that one in seven Americans is black (it's actually about 12.85% or closer to one in eight, but since we are talking about presidential terms, seven is an easier figure to handle), must Americans from now on elect an African-American every seven election cycles to prove they aren't racist? And must they not just have a black person run, but actually win the election — meaning that any white person's campaign (for the presidency or simply to be his party's candidate) is doomed ahead of time, meaning in turn, the parties may have no whites even thinking of being a candidate every seventh election cycle? By the way: must Americans elect an African-American exactly every 28 years — regardless of circumstances — or must they elect every seventh president a black man, i.e., taking into consideration the number of terms of the intervening six presidents, that is, counting a (supposedly white) single-termer's four years in the White House and a (supposedly white) two-termer's eight years as one each (i.e., as one each of the intervening six presidents)?
Maybe the solution is even more drastic: instead of electing a black man every seven election terms, Americans must make up for the 220 years without an African-American at the helm; meaning that the next six presidents (the total number of white males in the White House, 43, divided by 7) must be black. This, in turn, can only mean that no white politician may run for the supreme office (or even for the party's candidacy), whether in the Democratic party or the Republican Party, at least, until 2032 and possibly (should all candidates win reelection) until 2056.
And while we're at it, how about women? Must we elect a woman every second presidential contest? And again, must we start afresh (i.e., electing every seventh president a black and every second one a woman) or must we — again — make up for the previous 220 years — meaning we can only have blacks as president until 2032 and only females as presidents (one out of seven of whom is a black female, naturally) until the year… 2228?
What is the point about these questions? The point is as follows: Make no mistake about it. Should Obama win the election, the hand-wringing and wild charges about American racism — both at home and abroad — will at best cease temporarily. Any opposition to President Obama's policies will be construed as racism "rearing its ugly head" again.
And at best (at best, according to the — non-thinking — bean-counters, that is), in the faraway future, we will be told by the snickerers and the snorters: "Well yeah, a black American was elected in 2008 (even reelected in 2012), but that was a one-time travesty!"
Or they will say that oh, sure there is an African-Americans (there are African-Americans) whom Americans have elected president, but… his (but their) skin color wasn't dark enough. "Would they ever" — insert knowing ironic smile here — "elect a really dark Negro?"
Why do I think this? Why do I know this? How can I be so sure of it? Because it has already come up. Every time Obama inches forward, we see a resurgence in the tales of Barack Obama getting assassinated.
So first, we get snickering and snorting that (of course) America will never elect a black man president. When the prospect of a black man acceding to the presidency becomes distinctly possible (and even probable), we get snickering and snorting that (of course) that president (or that candidate) will be shot dead.
Why does this come up? Because Americans — or certainly, conservative Americans from small town America — must be accused of something sinister.
It doesn't matter if the nation's sports stars are black, it doesn't matter if the nation's top film stars are black, it doesn't matter if a nation's top generals are (or have been) black, it doesn't matter if the largest cities' mayors are (or have been) black, it doesn't matter if the secretary of state is black, it doesn't matter if a main party has chosen a black man to run for the presidency (whether he wins or not). As for electing a black man president, I would happily vote for a person such as Michael S Steele, Thomas Sowell, Walter Williams, Larry Elder, Shelby Steele, and (until recently) Condoleeza Rice.
But, again: all that doesn't matter: Americans — or certainly, Americans from small town America (the conservatives who usually vote for Republicans) — must be accused of something sinister. If it isn't racism, it's fascism. If it isn't fascism, it's something else. Americans must be treacherous, they must be greedy, they must be warmongers, they must be reactionary, they must be clueless. And… they must be racist. (Incidentally, has it ever occurred to you — has it ever occurred to our Liberal friends that what they think — what they are convinced they "know" — about run-of-the-mill Americans from small town America might actually be perfectly representative of the alleged racism that they deplore in those run-of-the-mill Americans' sentiments towards the black race? Notice that what the leftists accuse white, conservative, Waspish Americans of — nay, what they are convinced represents those Americans' entire reality — is far more derogatory and denigratory than the alleged racism that those Americans allegedly feel towards a race such as the black one.)
This is why we have what Mark Steyn calls it "Obama assassination porn." If/When Obama is felled by a bullet, the liberals will have a field day (or rather a field, week, month, year, decade, etc…) bemoaning that "America", i.e., that conservative racist America is what killed America. (But nations do not commit assassinations, nor do unorganized racial groups; only individuals do.)
Incidentally, what is frightening to envision, with all these martyred Obama fantasies and all this alleged racism floating around, is that the theoretical murder of Barack Obama would be (far) more profitable to the Democratic Party than to any racist individual or, certainly, to anybody supposedly embodying conservative America. If a Democrat really wanted his party to win, having their black candidate assassinated a few days before the election (along with the ensuing outrage and commotion) would ensure the party's near-certain capture of the White House. (Difficult to envision? As Jerry Bowyer points out, most presidential assassins have been rather of a leftist bent.)
Whatever the case, the basic truth about racism is as follows: racism is far less an accurate description of an attitude prevalent in a given society, in a given individual, than it is a weapon that is wielded to demonize one's opponents while making oneself appear heroic by parroting (and by doing nothing else than parroting) politically correct platitudes. More often than not, in other words, the fight against alleged pockets of racism is nothing more noble than a self-serving act of self-praise.
In the mean time, Superfrenchie, a resident of suburban Washington DC, can’t, in his zealous pursuit of pity, figure out the difference between a nationality and a race. He seems to find greater enlightenment in a nation where, unless propagandized and suppressed, sports fans ‘monkey chant’.
The French and racism - This brings us to another observation. The French people of European descent, with the exception of those descended from recent intra-European immigration (mainly from Italy, Spain, Poland), have no practical experience of racism from the receiving end. Here, I must mention the recent formulation of “anti-white racism”, but just to say that it’s both an epiphenomenon and irrelevant to the issue at hand. This absence of personal experience regarding racism explains why stereotypes against black people are so handy for the French who discuss racism. More clearly: French experience as emitters of racism toward black people is used as a reference to understand the feelings elicited by French bashing. This might offend some people, but it’s not rocket science. We always use the known to figure out the unknown.
Which is puzzling when you’re atmospherically accusing people largely of European origin of ‘racism’, when in fact, they were pelted all of their lives with reasons to think that European arts, culture, style, etc., were to be admired. In fact, those non-Europeans who don’t see the incessant imposition of the message about “see, we’re übermenschen because of our [opinions of our own lifestyles/inanimate products we’re selling you/opinions of you.]”
Any nominally skilled speaker of the English language would allege bigotry, not racism, but even at that, it can hardly be called bigotry when most of them have come to this conclusion through interpersonal experience, often going back decades of pedantic repetition.
SF’s insane assertion comes from an even longer history of prejudice that he should not be under any illusions about. The Republic’s policy on the handing of race is sound and highly principled. Many in the public, even the ‘educated’ babbling away in the ‘society of debate’ leave a great deal to be desired. Not just in the fundamentally monolithic nature of taking up outlying opinions, but within a bracket, for the sake of attention-seeking, but the underlying cultural habit of seeing nations as predictable entities comprising something-like-race and the treatment of their opinions of it with all the seriousness of a international sports league table.
Quite simply, that practice is a primitive thing for adults to engage in, yet those who do believe that they are illuminating us with their opinions based largely on an assumed image of a people-cum-race they like to opine about as a undifferentiated whole called “America”, or in the public’s gentle, infallible wisdom as ”les Ricains” or “les Amerloqs”, among other things as if their nation-state fixation wasn’t itself a form of bigotry with which they would like to write on your forehead.
Can anyone — an American or a European or a third-party national — imagine going to a football game (or a basketball game!) in the United States, and having the black players submitted to a litany of racial insults?
Strangely enough — given the Europeans' propensity to giving the Yanks lessons on solidarity, harmony (racial, social, and otherwise), and "humanistic" ties between men of all colrs and creeds — that is far from unheard at European football (i.e., soccer) games. Reporting from Paris is Jerome Pugmire:
Warming up on the sidelines, a black player jogs toward fans at the Parc des Princes soccer stadium. As he gets closer, a barrage of monkey chants explodes — "OOOH! OOOH! OOOH!" — and racist insults fill the air.
Such scenes are increasingly common at the home stadium of Paris Saint-Germain, or PSG, one of France's top soccer teams. And they stain elite soccer leagues elsewhere in Europe, raising fears a global sport that calls itself "the beautiful game" is getting uglier.
…Soccer, with its many black stars, should be a showcase of multiracial harmony — especially in France, which draws heavily on talent from its former African colonies.
Instead, brawling soccer fans have emerged as the extreme fringe of a deeply troubled France — one whose problems include grappling with stiffening resistance to immigration. After the riots that engulfed immigrant-dominated French suburbs last year, beer-fueled racism in soccer has taken on an even more menacing tinge.
Unlike soccer hooliganism elsewhere, in which the antagonists are fans of rival teams, the clashes outside Parc des Princes are largely between fans rooting for the same team — PSG.…
PSG, where George Weah of Liberia and Ronaldinho of Brazil once displayed their magic, is not alone in facing racist outrages.
In Spain, Barcelona striker Samuel Eto'o of Cameroon threatened to walk off the field after Zaragoza fans subjected him to monkey chants in February. In Italy, right-wing fans have displayed Nazi and fascist symbols and anti-Semitic banners at Rome's Stadio Olimpico.
But some black players say the atmosphere at Parc des Princes has become intolerable.
"I'd have to think twice before setting foot there again," Senegal-born Patrick Vieira, a midfielder for the French national team, said.
During one match, a fan yelled at PSG midfielder Vikash Dhorasoo, a France international midfielder of Indian origin, "Go sell peanuts in the Métro." It was among the least offensive shouts in a tirade of vulgar epithets for blacks.
As the 2006 World Cup draws closer, we have more examples of European sportsmanship and sophistication from Spain.
We should be very grateful for the Europeans on this planet. If it weren't for them, we would not realize to what extent America is a racist country and culture. (As I have personally had the blessed opportunity to discover several times.) It is true that places like Europe (indeed, any place that is not the U.S.), and above all France, serve as a real model of racial integration and harmony that the oafish Yanks should emulate, if only they shared the Europeans' capacity of reasoning and their sense of sophistication.
In fact, a big part of the Euros' argument is that they complain that people (Americans or "un-lucid" Europeans) are generalizing in an unfair way; if only those people would understand the exact of the problem, they would see (somehow) that racism (or anti-semitism or whatever form it takes) is not that big of a problem; or it is a problem, but they are doing their best to fight it.
Not a bad argument; unfortunately, when it comes to examples (large or small, and real or imainged) of racism in America, such considerations are swept aside in favor of …generalisations, scorn, and disgust with American racism. In fact… this brings us to the most important point about European racism. Indeed, as we ponder the words of Martin Luther King Jr, pause to reflect on the fact that the most offensive, the most revolting, and the most dangerous part of European racism has not been treated above.
And that is anti-Americanism.
As eminent British historian Paul Johnson has written,
anti-Americanism is a function of cultural racism. … The view is that sophisticated, civilized Europe has nothing to learn from "adolescent" America. … This cultural racism is particularly directed at the supposedly "know-nothing" President George W. Bush and his "gung ho" Texas background. The European intelligentsia gets its notion of America chiefly from Hollywood, TV soaps like Dallas and fiction. Few of them have any experience of America, outside of three or four big cities. Middle America is unexplored territory. The fact that the U.S. has proved a highly efficient crucible for melding different peoples into a human sum greater than its constituent parts is seen as a misfortune in Europe because it produces a cultural stew that lacks purity of any kind and is therefore at the mercy of commercial forces.
European elites tend to look at Americans as a subcivilized mass, whose function is to be obedient consumers in a system run by big business. The role of competition in U.S. economic life — and in every other aspect of life — is ignored, because competition is something Continental Europeans like to keep to a minimum and under careful control. … Although Americans are seen as highly materialistic consumers, they are also despised and feared for their spiritual interests, their participation in religious worship and their subscription to creeds of morality. Europeans see no inconsistency in their condemnation of the U.S. for being at one and the same time paganly unethical and morally zealous.
The truth is, any accusation that comes to hand is used without scruple by the Old World intelligentsia. Anti-Americanism is factually absurd, contradictory, racist, crude, childish, self-defeating and, at bottom, nonsensical.
In that respect, the Euros' haughty view of "adolescent" Americans (aka their "American friends", which is more like the neighborhood's dopey American teens) is little better than the cry, "Go sell peanuts in the Métro." In fact, it is just as bad or worse. Read Johnson's entire text…
The International League Against Racism and Anti-Semitism said that this
did not involve specific discrimination of the kind confronted by Arabs
and blacks, but held that anti-white racism “exists, and there are no
taboos or hesitation about saying so.”
The organization has become a co-plaintiff in an apparently racially
motivated aggravated assault case involving an attack on a white male.
According to press reports, the suspect was shown on a video
surveillance tape wielding a broken bottle and shouting, “Dirty white,
dirty Frenchman,” in French and Arabic.
“Today,” wrote Pierre-André Taguieff, a sociologist and historian, “in
certain ‘difficult neighborhoods,’ so-called poor whites are the primary
victims of a majority of so-called poor non-whites. The rejection of
whites is, in turn, encouraged by Islamist propaganda that is hostile to Muslims’ integration.”
Obviously, the majority white population in France is not under siege.
And the Muslims here (an estimated five million people, including
citizens and the country’s largest immigrant group) continue to face
various forms of prejudice and exclusion.
But the anti-racism league’s stance gives substance to an intensifying
antagonism at the heart of French society from years of failed
integration — and to what is seen by large segments of French society as
Muslim unwillingness to accommodate the law, customs and lifestyle of
the majority.
A survey published Oct. 25 by the Ifop polling organization
underscores the clash. It reported that 60 percent of the French
consider that “the influence and visibility of Islam in France” is too
great, 68 percent believe that Muslims’ nonintegration is their own
fault, and that refusal of Western values, fanaticism and submission are
the words that best correspond to the idea they have of Islam.
With the possibility of France entering recession next year, and
alongside recent cases of murder and alleged plots by Muslim extremists,
this amounts to real grief and tension.
Despairingly, both are compounded by the incapacity of successive
governments to deal with the Muslims’ role in France with anything like
decisive engagement.
First, no president here has ever made a priority of massive investment —
call it high dosage affirmative action — in the newcomers’ future
education and employment.
Second, no leader has ever sought to enforce specific standards for Muslim assimilation.
Those standards are not a vague, nonintuitive notion in France. They correspond to the secular character of the French republic,
which promises freedom of religion for all, but also demands a complete
absence of religion from the activities of the state — and bars the
insertion of religion by anyone into those activities.
… Coming on top of greater Muslim alienation and more complaints about
Islam from the white majority, the current government effort is the
rough equivalent of the denial that often has been the reflexive
response to issues involving everyday racism here since the end of
French colonialism in the 1960s.
Clearly, mumbling that the automatic equality attached to French
citizenship and the fairness of French society are sufficient guarantees
for Muslim integration is a dead incantation in 2012.
It’s hard to be optimistic about France buying or charming back an
estranged community that in some neighborhoods lives life as a partially
parallel society. Many Muslims might ask, Why should I accept the
values of the republic when I believe they function mostly in theory?
An extensive affirmative action program, with clear school and job entry
quotas might work, but it cannot come now without an accommodating and
assimilating new face offered as a quid pro quo from the Muslim side.
And so we here we have it: as more than a few of us have been predicting over the years, including myself in an in-depth post before the 2008 vote, the 2008 election of Barack Obama would not end the endless accusations of racism and/or cluelessness towards the average (white) American — nor indeed would Obama's reelection four years later.
… the basic truth about racism is as follows: racism is far less an
accurate description of an attitude prevalent in a given society, in a
given individual, than it is a weapon that is wielded to demonize one's
opponents while making oneself appear heroic by parroting (and by doing
nothing else than parroting) politically correct platitudes. More often
than not, in other words, the fight against alleged pockets of racism
is nothing more noble than a self-serving act of self-praise.
As James Taranto puts it (thanks to Instapundit), Antiwhite bigotry has gone mainstream, and indeed, over here in Europe, Louise Couvelaire proves that by stating in Le Monde, aka France's newspaper of record, that four years after the election of the first African-American president,
"the black community and minorities in general have reason to worry."
Because no candidate has received such an important part of the white
vote since Ronald Reagan as Mitt Romney has, it turns out that (to use the old formula) "racism has reared its ugly
head".
So, got that, white Americans? Voting against Barack Hussein Obama can only be proof of the unspeakable racism in the dark corners of your sinister soul…
Because "several hundred students" at the University of Mississippi burned signs with the name of Barack Obama while shouting racist slogans (even the Huffington Post raises its eyebrows by deliberately referring to this — rare — event as " 'riots' " with cynical-sounding quotation marks), The Post-Racial Era Will Still Have to Wait, as the title of her article says.
Le Monde goes on to describe the "most conservative zealots' outrageous attacks" in forcing Barack Obama to… make public his birth certificate, while quoting an Associated Press poll that claims that 51% of Americans express themselves in "explicitly racist" terms (up from 48% in 2008), while 56% of them demonstrated "implicitly xenophobic behavior" (up from 49%). (The claims have been, ahem, addressed by Hot Air and Newsbusters…)
The Le Monde writer ends her article with some quotes from a Professor of African-American Studies. Mark Naison of… Fordham university, a paragon of tolerance and free speech as is well known, claims that the Republican Party's "main motor is fear and white anger against people of color or minorities."
Il n'aura pas fallu attendre longtemps. A peine quelques minutes après
l'annonce de la victoire de Barack Obama, le 6 novembre, plusieurs
centaines d'étudiants de l'université du Mississippi ont brûlé des
pancartes portant le nom du président et scandé des slogans racistes.
…L'élection, en 2008, du premier président afro-américain de
l'histoire des Etats-Unis devait consacrer l'avènement d'une nouvelle
ère post-raciale. Quatre ans plus tard, la communauté noire et les
minorités en général ont de quoi s'inquiéter. Fin octobre, un sondage de
l'Associated Press indiquait que 51 % des Américains exprimaient des
idées explicitement racistes, contre 48 % en 2008, et que 56 % d'entre
eux affichaient des comportements implicitement xénophobes, contre 49 %
il y a quatre ans. Depuis son discours historique de mars 2008 intitulé
"De la race en Amérique", le locataire de la Maison Blanche, refusant
d'être le "président des Noirs", joue la prudence. Il n'a jamais abordé
ouvertement la question pendant son premier mandat.
… "La
rage d'une partie des Blancs qui s'est exprimée pendant la campagne de
2008 ne présageait rien de bon et elle s'est encore intensifiée, analyse Mark Naison, professeur d'études afro-américaines à l'université de Fordham, à New York. L'Amérique ne sera bientôt plus un "pays de Blancs" et ça les terrifie."
Les plus optimistes espèrent un rapport de forces plus égalitaire entre
les différentes communautés, mais au Parti républicain, la partie
s'annonce délicate. "Leur principal moteur est la peur et la colère des Blancs envers les gens de couleur ou encore les gays, poursuit Mark Naison. S'ils
lancent une opération de séduction envers les minorités, ils perdront
leur électorat de base, mais s'ils ne le font pas, ils n'auront aucune
chance de gagner. Il va falloir qu'ils trouvent un autre sujet
rassembleur."
to… Josh Feldman of Mediaite! During game seven of the World Series, Feldman noticed three cards
in the stands each bearing the letter ‘K’ and began wondering via
Twitter if the Klan was rearing its ugly head. He quickly dashed off an
embarrassing piece entitled “Wait, What’s That KKK Sign Doing at the
World Series?” He was apparently not the only one who believed that the
three K’s were somehow related to the Ku Klux Klan. Feldman’s piece
relied on a Twitterstorm of perplexed and angry messages from people who
also perceived racist intent behind the three K’s.
This is what happens when bandwagon-jumpers tune in to watch baseball
for the first time in their lives. If these people knew anything about
the sport they would know that ‘K’ is baseball shorthand for a
strikeout. It’s common for fans to tally strikeouts by holding up cards
with the letter ‘K’ on them. Three K’s means three strikeouts—not
Ku Klux Klan. Sheesh. Even I knew that and I haven’t watched an entire
baseball game in years. After the error was discovered, Mediate altered
the story, claiming that “some Twittters” made the foolish mistake, omitting the fact that the most prominent of these Twitterers was their very own Josh Feldman.
The whole incident would be funny if it weren’t so sad. Did these
people really think that the KKK crashed the World Series? Yes, they
probably did. As ridiculous as it sounds, they honestly believe that the
KKK is a force to be reckoned with in modern American life and not just
a negligible group of fringe yahoos who are justifiably held in
universal contempt.
Apocryphal KKK sightings are becoming increasingly common. In April, the University of Indiana had a minor panic
after news spread via Twitter that an honest-to-goodness klansman was
prowling the campus—with a whip no less. Crisis was averted when it was
discovered that the “klansman” was Father Jude McPeak, a Franciscan
friar dressed in the white garment of his order. The “whip” was actually
a rosary hanging from his belt.
At the height of last autumn’s racial unrest at the University of
Missouri, word of klansmen on campus went viral—just in time to prove
the student protestors’ point that their campus was infested with
racism. As you can probably imagine, the whole thing was a giant
hallucination. Payton Head, Mizzou’s student body president, did his
part to amplify the panic by pushing misinformation (or, more likely,
disinformation) through his Twitter and Facebook accounts. Payton Head
is black, by the way, and one of the main instigators of the insane
Black Lives Matter-inspired hysteria that rocked Mizzou in 2015.
The turbulent events of last autumn began when Head claimed that someone had screamed the n-word
at him from a passing pickup truck. I have my doubts that such an
incident happened at all because Payton Head is an agenda-pushing racial
arsonist and a liar. We know this at very least from his tweeting about
the illusory klansmen on his campus: “Students please take precaution.
Stay away from windows in residence halls. The KKK is confirmed to be
sighted on campus. I’m working with the MUPD, the state trooper [sic]
and the National Guard.” The Twitter rumors only got more outlandish
from there. Suddenly the imaginary klansmen were chanting “white power!”
One Twitterer seemed to believe that klansmen were throwing bricks
through dorm windows while enjoying police protection. How’s that for institutional racism?
Eventually Payton Head was forced to admit that the KKK was not on
campus. Duh. “I’m sorry about the misinformation that I have shared
through social media,” Head wrote on Facebook. “In a state of alarm, I
was concerned for all students of the University of Missouri and wanted
to ensure that everyone was safe. I received and shared information from
multiple incorrect sources, which I deeply regret.”
But Payton Head was not duped. He claimed to have been working with
the campus police, state police, and the National Guard. How could that
possibly have been true when in fact there never were any hooded bad
guys to speak of? Furthermore, the university says that the National
Guard wasn’t even on campus. Payton Head told a ridiculous lie that was
believed by far too many paranoid ninnies.
The only word to describe the insane fear of a weak and dying redneck
organization like the KKK is paranoia. It occurs to me however, that
many people don’t perceive paranoia to be a problem when racism is its
subject. Given the negative connotation of the word “paranoia” they of
course avoid using it, though they embrace it all the same. Dare I say
that our society, or at least segments of it, considers paranoia of
racism to be a virtue of sorts? Their attitude seems to be that racism
is so utterly loathsome that there can be no such thing as excess when
opposing it.
There are some people in this world, let’s just call them Social
Justice Warriors, who see a racist under every bed. I am intentionally
borrowing a Cold War phrase that was often used to discredit
anti-communists for perceiving “a communist under every bed.” The phrase
had a certain sting to it because it portrayed anti-communists as
hopeless paranoids—which they weren’t. Anti-communists weren’t looking
for communists under every bed but there were plenty to be found in
Hollywood (Lillian Hellman, Dalton Trumbo), in academia (Howard Zinn,
the entire Frankfurt school) in the news media (I.F. Stone, Carl
Bernstein), and in the so-called “civil rights movement” (Bayard Rustin,
Hunter Pitts O’Dell, Stanley Levison). By the late 1960s the communists
weren’t even hiding anymore; they were waving Viet Cong flags and
brandishing Mao’s little red books.
Yet despite the plethora of evidence that communists were indeed
burrowing into our societal institutions, some particularly ignorant
people still talk about anti-communism as if it were nothing more than
tilting at windmills. Now, some 25 years after the fall of the Soviet
Union we’ve come to embrace paranoia—real paranoia—as something
to be admired. The Don Quixotes of our time are Payton Head and his
allies yet we don’t mock them for being wrong in the same way that we
mocked anti-communists for being right.
The genuine paranoia of 21st Century race-baiters is
excused because it indicates a supposed consciousness of racial issues.
In the parlance of the Black Lives Matter movement these people are “woke”—which
is to say that their eyes are open to the reality of racism in America.
They see nothing wrong with crying wolf about racism because it shows
that their hearts are in the right place. Recall Payton Head’s Facebook
post in which he claimed that he was only worried about the students’
safety. And who could fault him for an abundance of caring? The rest of
us who don’t see imaginary men in white bedsheets are miscreants for not
perceiving racism in every aspect of modern American life. It’s a
messed up world we live in when paranoids get to lecture the rest of us
for not sharing their pathology.
Paranoia of any kind is unattractive and even dangerous. Granted,
people will always disagree about what constitutes paranoia. If one
person perceives a real threat and another does not, the second person
will think of the first as paranoid while the first person will think of
the second as blithely unaware. But which one is right? In a country
where fake hate crimes regularly spur the population into fits of rage, I
think we can safely say that the pathology resides mostly with the
Social Justice Warriors. There’s nothing wrong with us but there is
something very, very wrong with them. It’s time they paid a social
penalty for their crazed antics. Laugh at them. Scorn them. Call them
nutjobs because that’s what they are. Only when they cease to be
rewarded for their supposed good intentions will the hysteria end.
Among the Republican winners of the 2014 mid-terms is Tim Scott, the black South Carolinian who won his Senate seat in a landslide, making history in the process.
But even the Daily Mail seems to report on this landslide (!) victory mainly to report on America's alleged racism, i.e., to comment how "shocking" it is that Tim Scott is the first black man elected to the Senate. (Never mind the congressmen, the governors, the mayors, the business leaders, the sports stars, the movie and TV stars, the music stars, the occupant of the White House (!), etc, etc, etc…)
But isn't it possible that the true racism comes from the left — including the mainstream media itself? (There are quite a number of pretty outstanding comments in the comments section of the Guardian.) As I wrote in a post one year ago, a plethora of "inconvenient facts must be ignored or belittled by media people … in order to push the narrative that America is an intolerant hell hole of prejudice populated by hordes of despicable racists":
Every time I read a column [in which a member of the MSM] laments the racism he constantly finds among conservative groups … I wonder if he has ever heard about Tim
Scott. Given that for awhile, the legislator from South Carolina was
the only member of the United States Senate who is African-American, one
would think that his name might be — almost — as renowned as Barack
Obama's.
The explanation for Scott's relative obscurity is that he is a
Republican — one who is backed by Tea Partiers (endorsed by Tea Party
favorite Jim DeMint, Scott's Senate predecessor) and one from a Southern
state to boot. And were Scott better known, it would be far more difficult for people like Krugman to bewail the racism of Republicans and Tea Partiers, not to mention Southerners.
You would think that this black pauper's rise from rags to the
halls of the U.S. Senate is a living memorial to Martin Luther King's
dream. But because leftists (conveniently and self-servingly) define
themselves as the valiant fighters against the racism they (conveniently
and self-servingly) constantly find throughout the ranks of the
Republican Party, it comes as no surprise that South Carolina's
conservative Senator did not even receive an invitation to participate
in the 50th anniversary commemorations of MLK's Lincoln Memorial speech.
Should Krugman
need more evidence of his own prejudices, one could also mention Nikki
Haley and Bobby Jindal, Republican governors (both of Indian heritage)
backed by the Tea Party whose skin is about as dark as, if not darker
than, that of Barack Obama. Yes, they too were elected in states from
the former Confederacy.
As for blacks who are favorites of the Tea Party, either nationally
or locally, they include Herman Cain, Allen West, and Mia Love as well
as Thomas Sowell (the Stanford economist who deserves the Nobel Prize in
Economics at least as much as Krugman), Walter Williams, and Larry Elder. But all these African-Americans must be ignored, because for the Left, the only good "Negro" is the martyred "Negro"
— the one who constantly thinks he and his like are victims and
therefore votes for the victimization party (i.e., the Democrats).
Currently, one favorite of the Tea Party crowd for presidential
candidate in 2016 is Dr Benjamin Carson, a neurosurgeon who is offering a
free-market alternative to Obamacare that would keep prices down and
Washington's brand-new army of bureaucrats out of the health care
system. His skin, too, is darker than Obama's.
But all these inconvenient facts must be ignored or belittled by media people like Krugman in order to push the narrative that America is an intolerant hell hole of prejudice populated by hordes of despicable racists.