Monday, May 09, 2022

For the first two years of World War II, Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia were allies; Hitler and Stalin secretly planned and jointly began the war that inflicted such horror and destruction

As troops recently returned from Ukraine rolled through Red Square in armored personnel carriers, Putin justified his assault on Russia’s neighbor as a response to mounting violence by US- and NATO-backed fascists.

Thus writes Jeff Jacoby about the May 9 parade, during which Vladimir Putin held a Victory Day speech telling the country's soldiers that among various other things, "You are fighting for the Motherland, for its future, so that no one forgets the lessons of World War Two."

As Antony Beevor notes in his history of The Second World War, "In Soviet eyes the definition of 'fascist' included anyone who did not follow the orders of the Communist Party." Might that not be generalized, in post-communist times (and even perhaps in pre-communist, i.e., in Tsarist, times [although the foreign demonization would in the latter case involve another word than (the post-WWI) "fascist"]?), to "Russian eyes" and to "Russia's ruling party"? 

Back to Jeff Jacoby, who begs to differ regarding "the lessons of World War Two":

Just as Putin’s Ukraine narrative is a confection of nonsense — from his repeated insistence that NATO has been engaged in a hostile attempt to “encircle” Russia to his absurd contention that Ukraine is not a real nation and has no right to sovereignty — so too is the legend that Russia was an innocent victim of Adolf Hitler, and that the launch of World War II was a monstrous crime committed by Germany alone.

There is no denying that a vast number of Soviet citizens lost their lives in World War II. Without the Russian people’s appalling suffering and sacrifice, the Allies might not have triumphed in the end.

But there is also no denying that Moscow was Nazi Germany’s partner in unleashing the war, the deadliest in human history, in the first place. Victory Day is a good opportunity to review the record of Russian culpability in plunging the world into war — a record the Kremlin’s propagandists have been trying to obscure for decades.

World War II is commonly said to have started on Sept. 1, 1939 , when German forces invaded Poland. But it would perhaps be more accurate to date the start of the war nine days earlier. On Aug. 23, 1939, German Foreign Minister Joachim von Ribbentrop and Soviet Foreign Minister Vyacheslav Molotov signed a treaty of non-aggression, whereby their governments agreed to conquer and divide Poland and the rest of Eastern Europe. It was under the terms of this pact that the Nazi Wehrmacht moved into western Poland on Sept. 1 and Josef Stalin’s Red Army invaded Poland from the east 16 days later


“Soviet and German forces set up brutal occupation regimes in their respective spheres and forcibly transferred hundreds of thousands of Polish citizens to forced-labor sites,” recounts Mark Kramer, the director of the Cold War Studies Project at Harvard’s Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies

 … Devouring half of Poland didn’t slake Moscow’s appetite. In the months that followed the Nazi-Soviet takeover of Poland, as Hitler’s troops conquered Denmark, Norway, Belgium, Holland, and France and bombed much of London into rubble, Stalin’s forces continued their illegal war of aggression and conquest. Writes Kramer:

Even as the Red Army was imposing Soviet rule on eastern Poland, Soviet troops also began moving into the three Baltic states (Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania), which had enjoyed some two decades of independence after the First World War. In subsequent months, as Soviet military and state security forces continued to pour into the Baltic countries, they compelled the local governments to comply with Moscow’s demands. Eventually, in mid-1940, Soviet occupying forces replaced the indigenous governments with puppet regimes that voted for “voluntary” incorporation into the USSR. The same pattern was evident in the formerly Romanian territories of Bessarabia and northern Bukovina, which the Soviet Union occupied and annexed in late June 1940.

The only major impediment to the expansion of Soviet rule in Eastern Europe came in Finland, where the entry of Soviet troops at the end of November 1939 sparked a brief but intense war.

In short, for the first two years of World War II, Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia were allies. They secretly planned and jointly began the war that inflicted such horror and destruction. Later, of course, Hitler double-crossed Stalin and ordered the Wehrmacht to invade the Soviet Union in June 1941. But before that turning point, the two totalitarian powers cooperated closely. …

Armored vehicles rolled through Red Square in Moscow during a rehearsal for today's Victory Day military parade.

In 2014, Putin made it a crime for Russians to “spread intentionally false information” — i.e., to tell the truth — about the atrocities committed by Soviet forces during World War II. As a result, writes Kramer, “the brutality of the Soviet occupation of eastern Poland, including massacres and widespread rapes, is a taboo subject in Russia nowadays.” In much the same way, Putin has made it illegal for Russian journalists today to report on Moscow’s massive violations of human-rights crimes in Ukraine.

In his Victory Day remarks, Russia’s dictator linked the record of the Red Army in the 1940s with that of the Russian troops now fighting in Ukraine. There are indeed parallels between the two, though decidedly not the ones Putin wants the world to focus on.

From 1939 through mid-1941, Soviet Russia collaborated with the Nazis in wreaking slaughter and savagery on the nations of Europe. The regime that rules in Moscow today is of course not responsible for Stalin’s evil alliance with Hitler. But no one should be fooled as Putin seeks to cloak himself and his calamitous Ukraine war in the “heroic” history of World War II-era Russia. Moscow and Berlin together started that horrific war, and used it to impose a reign of tyranny across Europe. Germany no longer terrorizes its neighbors. Russia still does.

“Soviet and German forces set up brutal occupation regimes in their respective spheres and forcibly transferred hundreds of thousands of Polish citizens to forced-labor sites,” recounts Mark Kramer, the director of the Cold War Studies Project at Harvard’s Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies.

As is pointed out in a special Stalin's Final Secrets issue of the Géo magazine, Molotov denied the existence of a special protocol in the non-aggression pact until his 1986 death, and the truth did not surface until after the end of the Soviet empire in 1991. Most infamously, the special protocol allowed  the Führer and the Vozhd to carve Europe into zones of influence making it, as

Update: Spasiba, Tovarich Driscoll, who wrote about the same topic eight years ago… 

Update 2: This brings up the so-called "paranoid" "witch hunts" against communists in post-war America. Here is a question that is seldom brought up: Who was head of the Kremlin when the term "McCarthyism" was coined? A fellow by the name of Stalin. As for the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC), another question is, how many people are aware that the maligned council was not solely involved with communists? Indeed, it was formed the year prior to the Nazi/Soviet non-aggression treaty, in 1938, to investigate disloyalty by subversive organizations tied to either pro-Soviet communists or — yes — pro-German fascists?

Update 3: You know how Democrats and their left-leaning allies abroad always seem to be in the process of aiding America's enemies — and not just aiding them but providing them with the most generous of gifts — from the Ayatollahs' Iran to communist China? Well, it may sound depressing to learn that there is a "groundbreaking reassessment of the Second World War" which states that basically FDR and even Winston Churchill might belong to that very same group. In Stalin's War (A New History of World War II), we are told by Sean McMeekin that 

World War II endures in the popular imagination as a heroic struggle between good and evil, with villainous Hitler driving its events. But Hitler was not in power when the conflict erupted in Asia—and he was certainly dead before it ended. His armies did not fight in multiple theaters, his empire did not span the Eurasian continent, and he did not inherit any of the spoils of war. That central role belonged to Joseph Stalin. The Second World War was not Hitler’s war; it was Stalin’s war.

 … Hitler’s genocidal ambition may have helped unleash Armageddon, but as McMeekin shows, the war which emerged in Europe in September 1939 was the one Stalin wanted, not Hitler. So, too, did the Pacific war of 1941–1945 fulfill Stalin’s goal of unleashing a devastating war of attrition between Japan and the “Anglo-Saxon” capitalist powers he viewed as his ultimate adversary.
 
McMeekin also reveals the extent to which Soviet Communism was rescued by the US and Britain’s self-defeating strategic moves, beginning with Lend-Lease aid, as American and British supply boards agreed almost blindly to every Soviet demand. Stalin’s war machine, McMeekin shows, was substantially reliant on American materiél from warplanes, tanks, trucks, jeeps, motorcycles, fuel, ammunition, and explosives, to industrial inputs and technology transfer, to the foodstuffs which fed the Red Army.
 
This unreciprocated American generosity gave Stalin’s armies the mobile striking power to conquer most of Eurasia, from Berlin to Beijing, for Communism.

From the British edition:  

With Hitler dead and the Third Reich in ruins, Stalin created an immense new Communist empire. Among his holdings were Czechoslovakia and Poland, the fates of which had first set the West against the Nazis and, of course, China and North Korea, the ramifications of which we still live with today.

Until Barbarossa wrought a public relations miracle, turning him into a plucky ally of the West, Stalin had murdered millions, subverted every norm of international behaviour, invaded as many countries as Hitler had, and taken great swathes of territory he would continue to keep. In the larger sense the global conflict grew out of not only German and Japanese aggression but Stalin's manoeuvrings, orchestrated to provoke wars of attrition between the capitalist powers in Europe and in Asia. Throughout the war Stalin chose to do only what would benefit his own regime, not even aiding in the effort against Japan until the conflict's last weeks. Above all, Stalin's War uncovers the shocking details of how the US government (to the detriment of itself and its other allies) fuelled Stalin's war machine, blindly agreeing to every Soviet demand, right down to agents supplying details of the atomic bomb.

7 comments:

Jerryskids said...

And Hitler's reign of terror over Eastern Europe lasted only a few short years. Uncle Joe's reign of terror over Eastern Europe lasted a couple of generations.

Cardano Crusador said...

Yeah, and then the US and England conspired with the USSR.... so, does that make America a communist country? Asking for a friend.

Eric said...

Cardano Crusader …. How exactly did the US and England conspire with the USSR? Help me out here

Anonymous said...

Insipid!

Erik said...

Check out Sean McMeekin's Stalin's War (A New History of World War II)

His book contends that

1) "World War II endures in the popular imagination as a heroic struggle between good and evil, with villainous Hitler driving its events. But … Hitler did not inherit any of the spoils of war. … The Second World War was not Hitler’s war; it was Stalin’s war" … "as McMeekin shows, the war which emerged in Europe in September 1939 was the one Stalin wanted, not Hitler"

2) "McMeekin also reveals the extent to which Soviet Communism was rescued by the US and Britain’s self-defeating strategic moves, beginning with Lend-Lease aid, as American and British supply boards agreed almost blindly to every Soviet demand …

"This unreciprocated American generosity gave Stalin’s armies the mobile striking power to conquer most of Eurasia, from Berlin to Beijing, for Communism."

https://www.amazon.com/Stalins-War-New-History-World/dp/1541672798

Boarwild said...

Even Better: Bundeswehr historian Joachim Hoffman published “Stalin’s War of Extermination;, 1941 -1945: Planning, Realization, & Documentation”. Through exhaustive research - made possible by the Soviet collapse & opening of former Soviet archives- Hoffman is able to definitively prove that WWII was the result of Josef Stalin’s grand design. The Soviet plan was to embroil Germany in a war with the western democracies - a’la WWI - then strike west when she was weakened by attritional warfare & drive all the way to the English Channel thereby bringing all of Weatern Europe under the hammer & sickle. Hitler completely upset Stalin’s plan by knocking out France in 6wks & kicking Great Britain off continental Europe in four places: Dunkirk, Norway, Greece, & - later - Dieppe. Stalin’s plan was to attack Germany in the spring of 1942. Hitler beat him to the punch by launching Operation Barbarossa on June 22, 1941. Stalin & the Red Army were caught totally off guard. The main reason Soviet casualties were so horrendously high so early on - 3.5 million in as many months - is that the Red Army was buttressed up against the Western frontier in assembly areas getting ready for the planned attack.

Hoffman’s work has received the Federal German Govt seal of approval, which is no small feat when you remember that the Bundeswehr govt is loathe to approve anything shining any potential approving light on The Third Reich but this they did. Hoffman’s work has also been attacked by all the usual suspects/apologists for the Left accusing him of being pro-Nazi, et al. Link: https://www.amazon.com/Stalins-War-Extermination-1941-1945-Documentation/dp/0967985684/ref=sr_1_1?crid=29K6EVFY48CD1&keywords=stalins+war+of+extermination&qid=1652154393&s=books&sprefix=Stalin’s+%2Cstripbooks%2C143&sr=1-1


Hoffman’s work is also backed up by a former Soviet intelligence officer, one Victor Suvarov by name, in his definitive work, “The Chief Culprit”. His research mirrors Hoffman’s discoveries: https://www.amazon.com/Chief-Culprit-Stalins-Grand-Design/dp/1591148065/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2BM400438AS63&keywords=the+chief+culprit&qid=1652156215&s=books&sprefix=Suvarov+the+Chief+culprit%2Cstripbooks%2C115&sr=1-1

Bruce said...

Churchill seemed to be VERY wary of Stalin.

However, Roosevelt, being a dedicated socialist and thoroughgoing statist, was hot to trot.

Furthermore, pre-WW2, the nazis and the soviets had a cosy 'information sharing deal going. On top of that was the German use of military proving grounds in Russia to try out their tank designs. Interestingly, the soviets did NOT reciprocate by revealing their developments including the early T-34. BTW, remember that the basic mechanical design of the T-34 was a development of the US designed "Christie" tank, via the BT series. The soviets liked it because it was designed to be operated either with the tracks on, for soft or rough terrain, or on the large, rubber-tyred road-wheels. Germany had an impressive network of "high-speed" concrete roads by the mid 1930s and was steadily expanding this. It is entirely reasonable that these roads were not just for the benefit of German civiliams in their new KDF cars.They complemented the excellent rails system in their ability to re-deploy militsry assets very quickly,; a major lesson from WW1. In many places they "visited", the Wehrmacht engineers built high-quality concrete roads, many of which are in use to this day

Tanks with Christie suspensions were ideal for operation at high-speeds on such roads. Any dots joining yet. However, tracked "proper" tanks were a better choice for general use, hence the famous (but FAR from "perfect") T-34 had a more conventional drive setup.Note that at the same time there were almost NO paved roads in Russia, outside major cities. "General Winter" followed by a sloppy spring had acted as territorial bulwarks for centuries. Barbarossa was delayed several weeks by Hitlers dash to the Mediterranean, which, in turn was a preliminary operation to both prop up Mussolini's patchy performances and to secure more sea ports and the Ploesti oilfields in Romania, PRE Barbarossa.

Has anyone remembered that Stalin had another ace. A double agent called Sorge, who was well embedded in the Imperial Japanese intelligence biz. Stalin and his buddies were reading the daily mail between Japan and Germany, BEFORE war broke out. The "Great Game" continues.